Sub-theme 63: Antecedents and Consequences of Institutional Logics for Reasoning and Rationality
Convenors:
Patricia H. Thornton, Duke University, USA
William Ocasio, Northwestern University, USA
Julien Jourdan, Bocconi University, Italy
Session I: Thursday, July 02, 11:00 to 12:30, COM-3103
Materiality: Alternative Reasoning and Rationality
Chair: William Ocasio
Briana Preminger and Gili S. Drori
'Spatialized logics' along Jerusalem Western Wall: The layered space of logics at a heritage site
Hélène Lambrix
How material practices enacted to institutional logics contribute to the becoming of members?
Markus Perkmann, Maureen McKelvey and Nelson Phillips
Benefiting from institutional complexity: How organizations use boundary spaces to engage with minority logics
______________________________________________________________________
Opening Salvos by Patrica H. Thornton
______________________________________________________________________
GROUND RULES: Each session will have a chair discussion leader who will make short comments at the beginning of each session (no more than 5 mins.) and seed discussion. Each presenter should take no more than 15 minutes and use no more than 5 overhead slides to seed group discussion with provocative ideas and findings. We will allow approximately 10 minutes for discussion after each presentation and expect authors assigned to each session to formulate questions for other authors in your session. This format should allow more time for cumulative discussions at the end of each session. While most of you will not be formally charged with discussant duties, we still encourage you to read all of the papers and come with energy to engage in dialogue and help to develop knowledge from the theory and empirical findings of the papers. We are holding parallel sessions because our aim to be inclusive and developmental. We look forward to your collaboration and participation!
Opening Salvos by Patrica H. Thornton
______________________________________________________________________
GROUND RULES: Each session will have a chair discussion leader who will make short comments at the beginning of each session (no more than 5 mins.) and seed discussion. Each presenter should take no more than 15 minutes and use no more than 5 overhead slides to seed group discussion with provocative ideas and findings. We will allow approximately 10 minutes for discussion after each presentation and expect authors assigned to each session to formulate questions for other authors in your session. This format should allow more time for cumulative discussions at the end of each session. While most of you will not be formally charged with discussant duties, we still encourage you to read all of the papers and come with energy to engage in dialogue and help to develop knowledge from the theory and empirical findings of the papers. We are holding parallel sessions because our aim to be inclusive and developmental. We look forward to your collaboration and participation!
Session II: Thursday, July 02, 14:00 to 15:30, COM-3103
New Varieties of Hybrids
Chair: Julien Jourdan
Ziva Sharp, Nurit Zaidman and Dan Kaufmann
The role of non-reflexivity in facilitating and destabilizing organizational hybridity
Michel W. Lander, Pursey P.M.A.R. Heugens and Hans van Oosterhout
Performance or professionalism? An exploratory study of hybrid organizations' outcomes
Ali Aslan Gümüsay, Michael Smets and Tim Morris
‘God at work’: Institutional logics, organizational responses and resilience hybridity
Session III: Thursday, July 02, 16:00 to 17:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Logics and Micro Processes for Strategy and Agency - Room: COM-3103
Chair: Markus Perkman
Laura Claus and Shahzad (Shaz) Ansari
How organizational members cope with complexity by means of anchoring
Vanessa Pouthier and William Ocasio
Individuals' experiences of institutional complexity: A typology of challenges to collaboration
Magdalena Cholakova and Davide Ravasi
Individuals at crossroads: Cognitive complexity and affective appraisal in responding to multiple institutional logics
Parallel Stream B: Consequences of Logic Centrality, Strength, and Institutionalization - Room: PIERCE-404
Chair: Fabrice Cavarretta
Giulia Cappellaro and Tina Dacin
Institutionalizing hybrids in Italian health care: The case of public-private organizations
Lea Fuenfschilling and Bernhard Truffer
The rise of alternative institutional logics – Consequences for agency and field-level change
Benedetto Lepori and S. Kubra Canhilal
Variation in institutional pressures and organizational responses to pluralism
Session IV: Friday, July 03, 09:00 to 10:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Institutional Logics and Entrepreneurship - Room: COM-3103
Chair: Davide Ravasi
Patricia H. Thornton and Haochi Zhang
Cultural knowledge and entrepreneurial opportunities
Joshua T. Brown
Constellations of logics: Organizational identity construction in American religious universities (2000–2014)
Fabrice L. Cavarretta and Nathan Furr
An inquiry into the epistemic properties of entrepreneurs' theories of action
Parallel Stream B: Value Rationalization: Communicating and Translating Logics - Room: PIERCE-404
Chair: Shaz Ansari
Derek Harmon and Eero Vaara
A configurational model of communicative legitimation
Michael Hunoldt, Simon Oertel and Anne Galander
Being responsible: How CSR managers aim to implement CSR in their organizations
Jorien Pruijssers, Pursey P.M.A.R. Heugens and Hans van Oosterhout
Logics under pressure: How strategic responses to institutional complexity undercut institutional microfoundations
Session V: Friday, July 03, 14:00 to 15:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Conflicting Institutional Logics: Social Functions, Mechanisms, and Paradoxes - Room: COM-3103
Chair: Michael Smets
Anusha Satturu, Suhaib Riaz and Israr Qureshi
Developing paradoxes to maintain status quo: An organizational response to conflicting institutional logics
Noomi Weinryb and Stefan Arora-Jonsson
Lego or Tetris? A comparative study of philanthropists and the decomposability of institutional logics
Nick Taylor, Joeri Mol, Dean Pierides and Graham Sewell
Mercantilism 2.0? An institutional analysis of Sovereign Wealth Funds
Parallel Stream B: Competing Institutional Logics, Tools, and Coupling - Room: PIERCE-404
Chair: Tina Dacin
Kirsti Iivonen and Kathryn Fahy
Institutional logics as flexible resources: How Coca-Cola uses a community logic to respond to the obesity issue
Ingo Bode and Hannu Turba
Institutional ambiguity and schizophrenic reasoning: Lessons from the evolving field of organized child protection in Germany
Michelle Gittelman
Research paradigms as institutional logics: The rise of genomics in bio-medical research and the persuasive power of rationality
in science
Session VI: Saturday, July 04, 09:00 to 10:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: The Internstitutional System: Alternatively Framing Reasoning and Rationality - Room: COM-3103
Chair: Michel Lander
Sarah Maire, Hélène Delacour and Sébastien Liarte
Co-evolution of institutional logics framed with different rationalities: Rivalry, divorce or cohabitation?
Nicolas Battard, Thibault Daudigeos and Amélie Boutinot
From institutional logic precursors to salience: Tracking down institutional change through cultural repertoires
Pauli Pakarinen and Saku Mantere
Deregulation revisited: Institutional vocabularies in the central bank’s decision-making
Parallel Stream B: The Interinstitutional System: Alternatively Framing Reasoning and Rationality - Room: PIERCE-404
Chair: Patricia H. Thornton
Basak Topaler, Behlül Üsdiken, Ozgecan Kocak and Anil Divarci
Constrained marketization and organizational responses: Universities in Turkey
Margit Münzer
Being the pioneer in Europe? The French reform to separate banking activities from an institutional logics perspective
Kazuo Takeuchi
Market logic permeation in organizational field dominated by public and community logic
Session VII: Saturday, July 04, 11:00 to 12:30, COM-3103
Summary Comments and Future Directions
Chair: Patricia H. Thornton
Comments by Julien Jourdan, Davide Ravasi, William Ocasio, and Markus Perkman