Sub-theme 51: Valuation and Evaluation within and across Organizations

Charlotte Cloutier, HEC Montréal, Canada
Jean-Pascal Gond, City University London, UK
Louis-François Brodeur, HEC Montréal, Canada
Session I: Thursday, July 02, 11:00 to 12:30, COM-2106
Valuing Things
Chair: Charlotte Cloutier
Antony Kuhn, Yves Moulin and Hélène Rainelli-Weiss
Valuation on the market for collection stamps: How do judgement devices survive the move to electronic markets?
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Fabian Muniesa
Fabian Muniesa and Liliana Doganova
Setting the habit of capitalization: The pedagogy of earning power at the Harvard Business School, 1920–1940
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Germain Tesnière
Julie Labatut, Germain Tesnière and Eva Boxenbaum
The role of evaluation devices in the creation of new institutions: Breeding contracts under the "genomic" era in animal genetics
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Hélène Rainelli Weiss
Session II: Thursday, July 02, 14:00 to 15:30, COM-2106
Valuing through Rankings and Standards
Chair: Jean-Pascal Gond
Benoit Cret
Playing the accreditation game: Magical beliefs and opportunistic appropriation
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Lara Hale
Lara Anne Hale
Commensuration and legitimacy in standards
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Greg Molecke
Jonatan Pinkse and Greg Molecke
The social entrepreneur's evaluation paradox: When better social impact valuations do more harm than good
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Benoit Cret
Session III: Thursday, July 02, 16:00 to 17:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Valuing Institutions, Politics and the Public Enterprise - Room: COM-2106
Chair: Louis-François Brodeur
Andrea Mennicken
Privatization = economization? Privatization in the Prison Service of England and Wales since the 1990s
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Soorjith Illickal Karthikeyan
Soorjith Karthikeyan
Breaking do(a)wn? Category dissolution and audience evaluation in British politics, 1970–2005
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Susanna Alexius
Susanna Alexius and Jenny Cisneros Örnberg
Mission(s) impossible? Configuring values in the governance of state-owned enterprises in Sweden
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Andrea Mennicken
Parallel Stream B: - Room: PIERCE-626
Session IV: Friday, July 03, 09:00 to 10:30, COM-2106
Valuating and Controlling
Chair: Andrea Mennicken
Omiros Georgiou and Lisa Jack
How investors and analysts evaluate fair values: Assessing linkages between users and standard setters using resonance and dissonance
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Christina Mauléon
Adrián Pablo Zicari, Marie-Léandre Gomez, Philippe Lorino, Mathias Waelli and Jean-Yves Bonnefond
The challenge of measuring quality performance of healthcare services. The case of the DAN indicator in French hospitals
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Omiros Georgiou
Christina Mauléon
What's up with the numbers? A study of the translation of key performance indicators at a nuclear powerplant
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Adrian Zicari
Session V: Friday, July 03, 14:00 to 15:30, COM-2106
Valuing-ating as an Interactive Practice
Chair: Hélène Rainelli-Weiss
Marion Ligonie
Performativity in the making: Applying shared value theory
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Marina Bos-de-Vos
Marina Bos-de Vos, Kristina Lauche, Leentje Volker and Hans Wamelink
Negotiating value in inter-organizational work processes: Insights from architect-client interaction
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Pernilla Bolander
Pernilla Bolander, Kajsa Asplund and Andreas Werr
Intertwining practices: The intended and unintended consequences of changing performance evaluation practices in a Swedish school district
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Erik Wikberg
Lovisa Näslund and Erik Wikberg
Searching for the perfect Zorn: Valuation practices in auction houses
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Marion Ligonie
Session VI: Saturday, July 04, 09:00 to 10:30, COM-2106
Valuing Responsible Investing
Chair: Charlotte Cloutier
Christel Dumas
The becoming of value
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Stephanie Giamporcaro
Calculability as politics in the construction of markets: The case of socially responsible investment in France
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Daniela Laurel-Fois
Daniela Laurel-Fois, Diane-Laure Arjalies and Nicolas Mottis
When valuation creates a field: The case of responsible investment reporting
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Christel Dumas
Session VII: Saturday, July 04, 11:00 to 12:30, COM-2106
Controversies and Valuation
Chair: Louis-François Brodeur
Olga Navarro-Flores and Émilie Fortin-Lefebvre
Evaluation, legitimacy and power arbitration. The case of NGOs in international development
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Thorsten Peetz
Daniel Nyberg, Christopher Wright and Jacqueline Kirk
Re-producing a neoliberal political regime: Competing justifications and dominance in the public debate over UK fracking
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Chantale Mailhot
Karl-Emanuel Dionne and Chantale Mailhot
Toward a modelization of the evaluation process in a controversy
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Daniel Nyberg
Thorsten Peetz
Valuation in organizational publics
Presenter(s)Discussant(s): Olga Navarro-Flores