Sub-theme 25: Social Evaluations in an Age of Disruption: Processes of Creation, Maintenance, and Destruction of Social Evaluations

Convenors:
Alexandre B. Bitektine, Concordia University, Canada
Patrick Haack, HEC Lausanne, Switzerland
Anastasiya Zavyalova, Rice University, USA
Session Time Corridor 1: Thursday, July 08, 07:00 to 12:30, Virtual Conference (EventsAir)
Session Time Corridor 2: Thursday, July 08, 16:00 to 20:00, Virtual Conference (EventsAir)
Welcome; Parallel Sessions: Sessions 1A & 1B, and Sessions 2A & 2B; Zoom beer
Break 1: 17:45 to 18:00
Michael Etter, Jonathan Bundy, Donald Lange and Anika Poli
Comparing Analytic and Affective Judgments after Media Coverage of Corporate Social Irresponsibility
Discussant(s): Rossetti et al.
Claudia Rossetti, Jenni Sipilä and Laura Marie Edinger-Schons
When corporate ethical responses after transgressions fail to alleviate consumers’ anger
Discussant(s): Wang & Weber
Wei Wang and Klaus Weber
It is hard to say sorry: Organizational apologies and audiences management
Discussant(s): Etter et al.
Tobias Samuel Brügger, Katja Rost and Jan Danko
Social evaluations of Christian entrepreneurs in a secular business world
Discussant(s): Esposito et al.
Ciro Donald Esposito, Nachoem Wijnberg, Balázs Szatmári and Jonathan Sitruk
Getting off to a Good Start: Emerging Scientific Fields and External Financing
Discussant(s): Kim & Ha
Hyejun Kim and Jaekyung Ha
User before entrepreneur: When user-motives can signal commitment to customers
Discussant(s): Brügger & Rost
Betül Altunsu
From incomprehensibility to negative-taken-for-grantedness: The evolution of cultural-cognitive illegitimacy evaluations
Discussant(s): Wakeman
S. Wiley Wakeman
The benefit to being rotten: How stigma facilitates the radicalization of innovation
Discussant(s): Gorji et al.
Yasaman Gorji, Alexandre B. Bitektine and Arash Heshmati
Award stigma: A study in Hollywood movie industry
Discussant(s): Dong et al.
Lin Dong, Bryant A. Hudson, David Moura, Lee Jarvis and Elizabeth Goodrick
Stigma Transfer and Amplification: Owlcatraz and the Naming of a Football Stadium
Discussant(s): Altunsu
Andrew Argue and Thijs A. Velema
Confusion and consensus as mechanisms for category spanning penalties in social evaluations: Evidence from the social-tagging of PC video games by producers and audiences
Discussant(s): Forgues et al.
Ben Li, Bernard Forgues and Julien Jourdan
The consequences of status loss on the evaluation of market actors
Discussant(s): Wagner & Delmestri
Elisabeth Wagner and Giuseppe Delmestri
What is (not) being said – goal-based status dynamics
Discussant(s): Kondayya & Mani
Anupama Kondayya and Dalhia Mani
From criminals to demigods: Rhetorical history and status reclamation of the third gender in India
Discussant(s): Argue & Velema
________________________________________________________________________________________
16:00–16:10: Welcome

16:15–17:45: Session 1A – Stigma Management [Chair: Anastasiya Zavyalova]: Etter et al.; Rossetti et al.; Wang & Weber
16:15–17:45: Session 1B – Entrepreneurship and Social Evaluations [Chair: Alexandre B. Bitektine]: Brügger & Rost; Esposito et al.; Kim & Ha

18:00–20:00: Session 2A – The Evolution of Stigma [Chair: Anastasiya Zavyalova]: Altunsu; Wakeman; Gorji et al.; Dong et al.
18:00–20:00: Session 2B – Categories and Social Evaluations [Chair: Patrick Haack]: Argue & Velema; Forgues et al.; Wagner & Delmestri; Kondayya & Mani

20:30–22:00: Zoom beer for sub-theme participants
Session Time Corridor 3: Friday, July 09, 07:00 to 12:30, Virtual Conference (EventsAir)
Session Time Corridor 4: Friday, July 09, 16:00 to 19:00, Virtual Conference (EventsAir)
Parallel Sessions: Sessions 3A, 3B & 3C, and Sessions 4A, 4B & 4C; Closing
Break 1: 17:00 to 17:15
Jan Lodge and Wesley S. Helms
Moving beyond fighting the labels: A managerial model of stigma buffering through target-relational identification
Discussant(s): Zyglidopoulos et al.
Stelios Zyglidopoulos, Naomi Gardberg, Laura Illia, Elanor Colleoni and Stefania Romenti
How to mitigate the impact of fake news on corporate reputation
Discussant(s): Lodge & Helms
Leif Brändle, Michael Howard and Elisabeth Berger
Intertwined? The Evolution of Social Evaluations and Disruptive Technology Networks
Discussant(s): Cummins
Matt Cummins
'I used to mean something in this town': Tacit status symbols in the workplace
Discussant(s): Brändle et al.
Gonzalo Conti
From the eyes of the beholder. A micro-level perspective on the problem of markets in welfare services
Discussant(s): Paunova
Minna Paunova, Daniel Hardt and Sotiris Lamprinidis
Gender, nationality, and age effects in student evaluations of teaching
Discussant(s): Conti
Moritz Gruban and Matthieu Légeret
Do behaviors reflect individual legitimacy judgments? A behavioral experiment on normative and instrumental concerns
Discussant(s): Thaler et al.
Anna Jasinenko, Patrick Haack, Andre Baechtiger and André Bächtiger
The role of consensus in legitimation through deliberation: An experimental approach
Discussant(s): Schreck et al.
Philipp Schreck, Gonzalo Conti and Nils Kruse
The role of organizational motives and outcomes in the formation of legitimacy judgments
Discussant(s): Jasinenko et al.
Julia Thaler, Alexander Pinz and Martin Sievert
Legitimacy judgment formation – Experimental evidence from citizen participation settings
Discussant(s): Gruban & Légeret
Carlotta Cochis and Paula Ungureanu
Framing organizational scandals during emergencies. Evidence from retirement homes scandals in Italy during COVID-19
Discussant(s): Cudennec & Huynh
Arnaud Cudennec, Chang-Wa Huynh and Chang-Wa Huynh
A Cultural Lockdown? Categorical Atypicality and Cultural Products’ Evaluations under the COVID-19 Lockdown
Discussant(s): Karmali et al.
Shazia Karmali, Roy Suddaby and Cheryl Mitchell
Performative legitimacy and public governance during a global pandemic: A dramaturgical analysis of the social value judgements of public health officers in Canada
Discussant(s): Manchha et al.
Asmita Manchha, Kirsten A. Way, Ken Tann and Michael Thai
Social Construction of the Stigma of Working in Aged Care: Implications for Health Professionals’ Work Intentions.
Discussant(s): Cochis & Ungureanu
Will Harvey, Navdeep K. Arora and Thomas Roulet
Preparing for a fall from grace: Collective sense-making of stigma among white-collar inmates
Discussant(s): Dewan & Simons
Yasir Dewan and Tal Simons
Scandal, ideology, and stigma
Discussant(s): Yu
Yinmiao (Maxine) Yu
Damaged goods in the labor market? How social and historical aspirations influence organizational decisions to employ actors with misconduct records
Discussant(s): Sadri & Lyons
Mohamad Sadri and Brent Lyons
CEOs’ characteristics and stakeholders’ disapproval of firms in stigmatized industries
Discussant(s): Harvey et al.
________________________________________________________________________________________
16:00–17:00: Session 3A – Managing Social Evaluations [Chair: Patrick Haack]: Lodge & Helms; Illia et al.
16:00–17:00: Session 3B – Status at the Individual Level [Chair: Alexandre B. Bitektine]: Brändle et al.; Cummins
16:00–17:00: Session 3C – Stigmatized Categories [Chair: Anastasiya Zavyalova]: Conti; Paunova

17:00–19:00: Session 4A – Exploring Legitimacy with Experiments [Chair: Alexandre B. Bitektine]: Gruban & Légeret; Jasinenko et al.; Schreck et al.; Thaler et al.
17:00–19:00: Session 4B – COVID-19 and Social Evaluations [Chair: Patrick Haack]: Cochis & Ungureanu; Cudennec & Huynh; Karmali et al.; Manchha et al.
17:00–19:00: Session 4C – Social Dynamics around Stigma [Chair: Anastasiya Zavyalova]: Harvey et al.; Dewan & Simons; Yu; Sadri & Lyons

19:00: Closing Remarks
Session Time Corridor 5: Saturday, July 10, 07:00 to 12:30, Virtual Conference (EventsAir)