Sub-theme 05: [SWG] Valuation and Social Evaluations: Giving Value to Evaluations
Convenors:
Ana M. Aranda, Católica Lisbon, Portugal
Julien Jourdan, HEC Paris, France
Thomas Roulet, University of Cambridge, United Kingdom
Session I: Thursday, July 07, 11:00 to 12:30, TC.3.21
Introduction
Chair: All convenors
Jana Kim Gutt and Kirsten Thommes
Speaking of performance: Evaluating team members’ performance with open-ended audio comments
Discussant(s): Jean-Baptiste Gartner
Jean-Baptiste Gartner, Célia Lemaire, Luc Brès and André Côté
Miscompromises in orders of worth and their consequences for collective action in organization: A case study of valuation
in an healthcare organization
Discussant(s): Paolo Aversa
Paolo Aversa, Alex Howard and Maria Makarova
The social attribution of innovation: Uncovering
the heads behind the guillotine
Discussant(s): Jana Kim Gutt
Session II: Thursday, July 07, 14:00 to 15:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Stigma - Room: TC.3.21
Chair: Ana Aranda
Julien Cusin and Vincent Maymo
The banker’s evaluation of the post-bankruptcy entrepreneur’s dilemma when entering a relationship: What stigma is attached
to an imperfect entrepreneurial itinerary?
Discussant(s): Christian Hampel
Christian Hampel and Elena Dalpiaz
Rising from the ashes: How new ventures use moralizing narratives to reform in response to a legitimacy crisis
Discussant(s): Sara Mahabadi
Sara Mahabadi, Arvind Karunakaran and Lisa E. Cohen
Screening for the startup savior: The Paradox of fine-grained information gathering and the bbsession over “ideal” founder
characteristics during the evaluation of early-stage ventures
Discussant(s): Julien Cusin
Parallel Stream B: Disagreement, Decoupling and Valuation - Room: D2.0.038
Chair: Julien Jourdan
Elanor Colleoni, Patrick Haack and Laura Illia
Agreeing while disagreeing: Forms of consensus and the emergence of a new status quo during institutional change
Discussant(s): Michael Etter
Marjo Siltaoja
The Punch: Violence Towards Nonhuman Animals as an Organisational Legitimacy Threat
Discussant(s): Elanor Colleoni
Michael Etter
The polarization of social evaluations: How judgment disagreements about organizations escalate
Discussant(s): Marjo Siltaoja
Session III: Friday, July 08, 09:00 to 10:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Ethics and Norms - Room: TC.3.21
Chair: Thomas Roulet
Cassandra Chambers
Nonmonetary reward systems, counterproductive behavior, & responses to sanctions in open collaboration environments
Discussant(s): Stephan Leixering
Maxim Voronov and Gerardo Patriotta
Theorizing the role of values and institutionsin global crises
Discussant(s): Cassandra Chambers
Stephan Leixnering and Martin Kornberger
Organization and ethics: Towards an integrative framework of evaluation and action
Discussant(s): Maxim Voronov
Parallel Stream B: Cultural Organizations - Room: D2.0.038
Chair: Julien Jourdan
Mathilde Jost
“Quality justifies the bill?” Uncovering the path from legitimacy to experts’ reputation in creative industries. Evidence
from French gastronomy
Discussant(s): Cleo Silvestri
Andrew Argue and Thijs A. Velema
How
do producers bridge the cognitive gap between novelty and legitimacy in social evaluations?
Taiwanese restaurants’ use of visual artifacts to increase the cognitive
fluency of atypical products
Discussant(s): Mathilde Jost
Cleo Silvestri and Markus Perkmann
Singing a different tune: Distinction dynamics among film critics
Discussant(s): Andrew J. Argue
Session IV: Friday, July 08, 11:00 to 12:30, TC.3.21
Stigma
Chair: Thomas Roulet
Alessandro Piazza and Mohamad Sadri
Organizational stigma, corporate lobbying, and the nonmarket boundaries of the firm: Evidence from the U.S. Arms industry
Discussant(s): Patrick Haack
Patrick Haack, Margarita Cruz and Jan Goldenstein
Population replacement and the transfer of stigma: Evidence from the U.S. Luxury Hotel Industry
Discussant(s): Alessandro Piazza
Session V: Friday, July 08, 14:00 to 15:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Experiments and Legitimacy - Room: TC.3.21
Chair: Ana Aranda
Julia Herzum, Martin Sievert and Bernd Helmig
Effects of corporate environmental activities on evaluators’ propriety beliefs: Experimental evidence on individual legitimacy
judgments
Discussant(s): Moritz Gruban
Moritz Gruban and Aurélien Feix
What Pays Becomes Accepted: Why Organizations Can Advance Commodification Despite Enduring Losses in Moral Legitimacy
Discussant(s): Paul Gouvard
Angelo J. Deleo and Paul Gouvard
Organizational
suitability beliefs: Their cultural antecedents and their consequences for organizational
performance
Discussant(s): Julia Herzum
Parallel Stream B: Categories - Room: D2.0.038
Chair: Julien Jourdan
Wei Wang and Weiliang Zhang
National disputes, national membership, and customer ratings: Evidence from the United States–China trade war
Discussant(s): Kevin Curran
Kevin Curran, Jonathan Sitruk and Balázs Szatmári
Tarred with the same brush? New category regulation in stigmatized industries
Discussant(s): Guang Zhu
Guang Zhu and Filippo Carlo Wezel
High-engagement audience members and the evaluation structure of emerging markets
Discussant(s): Wei Wang
Session VI: Saturday, July 09, 09:00 to 10:30
- Parallel Stream -
Parallel Stream A: Entrepreneurship - Room: TC.3.21
Chair: Thomas Roulet
Mohamed Hassan Awad
The contested legitimation of inclusive new ventures
Discussant(s): Anna Jasinenko
Katharina Musil, Claudio Biscaro and Elena Bruni
The old lady and the floating beast. Constructing legitimacy through figures of speech
Discussant(s): Mohamed Hassan Awad
Anna Jasinenko, Patrick Haack and Derek J. Harmon
Covid-19’s system justifying effect on the legitimacy perceptions of business regulation
Discussant(s): Katharina Musil
Parallel Stream B: Crossing social Evaluations - Room: D2.0.038
Chair: Julien Jourdan
Hongqin Li, William S. Harvey and Geoffrey Wood
Celebrity and reputation uncertainty in a rapidly growing financial services firm
Discussant(s): Anne-Sophie Barbe
Pavlina Jasovska, Samuel MacAulay and André Sammartino
Only the impotent are pure? Understanding disreputable exchange in microbrewing
Discussant(s): Hongqin Li
Anne-Sophie Barbe and Nina Granqvist
The role of evaluations in the valuation of products belonging to the emerging de novo market category of quantum computing
Discussant(s): Pavlina Jasovska
Session VII: Saturday, July 09, 11:00 to 12:30, TC.3.21
Status
Chair: Thomas Roulet
Sumeet Malik, Chandrika Rathee, Julien Jourdan and Luis Gomez-Mejia
Status and cultural capital of Bollywood dynasties
Discussant(s): Matt Cummins
Matt Cummins
When Jay-Z comes to town: Status spillovers through objects
Discussant(s): Ben Li
Ben Li, Bernard Forgues and Julien Jourdan
The consequences of status loss on the evaluation of market actors
Discussant(s): Sumeet Malik